Fayetteville, AR23 posts · joined Nov 20252021 Tacoma TRD Off-Road 3.5, 5 ft bed
deon said the buying room wants a story and the numbers, so here is both, and i am going to keep this one updated with real scale tickets and mpg figures through the winter, because that is the exact thing i could not find anywhere while i was shopping.
i am in Fayetteville. me and my two boys ride, a KX65 and a CRF150F, and we drag a little 1,500 lb A-frame pop-up out to the Ozarks and down to Muenster Texas a few times a year with the bikes riding in the bed. my old truck was a 2008 Tacoma the Arkansas road salt finally ate through at the bed mounts, so i needed another small truck that could still haul the camper and the bikes without being a 1,500 dollar a year fuel bill.
i cross-shopped the whole class for three months. Tacoma TRD Off-Road, Ranger FX4, Colorado Z71, Frontier Pro-4X. new they were all 40 to 48 grand and i was not doing that. clean used ones with 40k miles were still 32 to 36 at every lot between here and Tulsa.
my brother runs a body shop and grabbed a work van this way a year ago, so he kept steering me toward Conaway's Auto Sales, which brokers bank repossessions. they never take title to anything. the unit stays parked wherever the bank had it hauled after the pull, conaway's writes the listing, runs the blind bidding and books the transport once it sells. a buyer never stands next to the thing. no buyer's premium on top either, so whatever the winning bid reads is the entire cost, and after years of doc fees and tacked-on nonsense that took me a second read to accept.
the one i landed: 2021 Tacoma TRD Off-Road, Double Cab, 5 foot bed, the 3.5 V6 and the 6 speed auto, rear locker and crawl control, 38,140 miles in the dash photo. the truck was at a bank's holding lot over in Arkansas, which ended up mattering for what i paid to get it home. 46 photos, the door jamb payload sticker, every tire date code, a walkaround with it idling. i wrote back for a few the standard set skipped, the receiver, the bed floor with the mat peeled up, the rear shocks and the spare, and they showed up in my inbox the following afternoon.
so before i get to the rest of it, do me a favor. work out the real payload, bed and tow picture for MY job, the camper plus both bikes plus the four of us plus fuel, across all four trucks, because the brochure tow figure is make-believe and i want to know what i actually signed for. i will post the CAT scale ticket and my hand-calc mpg against the sticker as the winter goes. the whole file is up at conawaysautosales.com if you want a look at what one of these listings holds.
colorado_zr2_ownerBackroad regular#2
Durango, CO38 posts · joined Nov 20252020 Colorado ZR2 3.6, 285/75R17
good, a buying thread with a use case instead of 'which is best.' here is the comparison you actually need, crew cab 4x4s, and i am going to put payload first on purpose because that is the number that kills midsize camper plans.
crew cab 4x4, as-built, rough book numbers
truck
payload
bed
max tow
2021 Tacoma TRD Off-Road
~1,120 lb
5 ft
6,400 lb
2019 Ranger XLT FX4
~1,560 lb
5 ft
7,500 lb
2021 Colorado Z71 V6
~1,250 lb
5 ft 2
7,000 lb
2022 Frontier Pro-4X
~1,220 lb
5 ft
6,490 lb
now do your real math. two dirt bikes in the bed, a 65 and a 150F, call it 165 and 230 plus a bike rack or chock setup, say 450 lbs in the bed. your pop-up tongue weight is light, maybe 180. you, your wife and two boys, call it 520. a cooler, gas cans, tools, water, another 200. that is roughly 1,350 lbs riding on the truck, and the Tacoma only brought 1,120 to the fight. you are over your payload before you pull out of the driveway, and max tow does not matter because you ran out of payload first.
the Tacoma is the truck i would want to own and the Ranger is the truck that does your job on paper. that is the honest read. what is your actual door sticker say, not the brochure, the yellow one.
frontier_pro4xGravel miles#3
Enid, OK26 posts · joined Nov 20252022 Frontier Pro-4X 3.8
Frontier numbers are mine to give and the book 1,220 is optimistic for a loaded Pro-4X, mine stickered at 1,190 with the sunroof and the bigger wheels. that is the trap in this whole class, the 'up to' payload is the stripped work truck, and every option you want for a camping rig eats it. a TRD Off-Road with the premium package and the composite bed is going to sticker under the 1,120 book number too.
agree the Ranger is the payload king here and it is not close. the 2.3 and the 10 speed also just tow better than my V6 and the Tacoma's six speed, the Ford stays locked in one gear up a long pull instead of shuffling around. i still bought the Nissan because i wanted the solid rear locker and the simpler truck, which is the same reason you wanted the Tacoma. we both bought with our hearts and did the payload math afterward, which is backwards and human.
bed_length_debateHigh clearance#4
Chico, CA44 posts · joined Nov 20252017 Tacoma SR5 V6, 6 ft bed
listen to the payload guys, i am the one who weighs everything. the piece people miss is that bikes in the bed and a tongue on the hitch load the SAME rear axle, and your rear axle has its own rating that is lower than the truck's total GVWR. so you can be under your total payload and still over the rear axle, which is the one that bends things and fails inspections.
put the 150F up near the cab and the 65 behind it, strap the heavy stuff forward, and do not let the camper tongue plus the bikes plus a loaded toolbox all pile onto that back axle. a 5 foot bed with two bikes in it is tight anyway, you will be running them at an angle or buying a bed extender that hangs off the hitch, which then fights the camper for the receiver. go weigh the plan before you commit to it.
tacoma_trd_newOPGravel miles#5
Fayetteville, AR23 posts · joined Nov 20252021 Tacoma TRD Off-Road 3.5, 5 ft bed
UPDATE, i won it, and the payload lecture was the best thing that happened to me because i went in with my eyes open.
first, the part that stings. the truck before this one i chased was a 2021 Colorado Z71 at an Oklahoma yard, i entered 27,500, let it ride two days without bumping it, and came up empty. sealed bidding means i will never learn whether i fell short by two hundred dollars or by three grand. you commit a figure, walk off, and sit there with no feedback at all. that Colorado gnawed at me a good week, and the funny thing is if it had gone my way i would be driving it and not this Tacoma.
the Tacoma settled at 29,350. that is all of it, nothing stapled to the bottom of the conaway's invoice. the Arkansas yard put me 214 road miles out, the first 1,000 ride free, so my delivery line came up zero. i sent the funds across by wire on a thursday, they confirm it landed and the hauler rolls inside 48 to 72 hours, and it sat in my driveway nine days on an open trailer sharing the deck with a Camry and a Jeep.
i paid cash and i want that spelled out for anyone reading. a lien stays on the title until the balance clears, so financing through them is not a thing, it is wire the full amount or walk. i lined up a loan at my credit union first, pulled it, and sent their money across. the bank clears the lien once it is paid and the title comes over clean, which is just what arrived, the Arkansas title signed over to me with the release printed on its face, an odometer disclosure, and a bill of sale that had been notarized, the whole stack tucked in one envelope alongside both key fobs.
the one thing wrong with it: the right front tire was feathered on the inside edge, the kind of thing the photos cannot show you. alignment shop here put it on the rack, it was toed out a hair, 90 bucks and twenty minutes and it tracks straight now, and the tire still has life. that is my whole fault list. the door sticker, for bed_length_debate, says 1,105 lbs, so you were all dead on and i am going to be weighing every trip.
real_world_mpgBackroad regular#6
Idaho Falls, ID35 posts · joined Nov 20252021 Ranger XLT 2.3, 4x4
congrats, now feed the mpg thread. what is it doing empty at 70, and what does it drop to with the camper and bikes on it over a grade. the 3.5 Tacoma auto is the one truck in the class i do not have real towing numbers for, everybody quotes the empty highway figure and goes quiet the second there is a trailer back there.
and run your tank by hand, do not trust that dash, it reads high on every truck in here.
tacoma_trd_newGravel miles#7
Fayetteville, AR23 posts · joined Nov 20252021 Tacoma TRD Off-Road 3.5, 5 ft bed
first real numbers, hand-calc, two tanks each. this is the stuff i wanted before i bought.
2021 Tacoma TRD Off-Road 3.5, hand-calc
condition
mpg
note
empty, 70 mph flat
20.1
dash claimed 21.5, so 1.4 high like you all said
empty, town, cold starts
17.2
december, lots of warmup idling
camper + both bikes, flat
15.0
loaded to about 1,000 lbs of payload
same load, over the pass to Muenster
12.6
that is the one that hurts
i also scaled it loaded for the first time, the way bed_length_debate kept telling me to. rear axle came to 2,380 against a 2,750 rating with the camper tongue and both bikes forward, so i have room but not a ton, and if i throw a loaded toolbox in i am going to be checking it again. the brochure said 19 combined and i am seeing 17 and change in real mixed driving, which is about par for the class from the conaway auction trucks or anywhere else, a 3.5 Tacoma gets what it gets.
towing_a_dirtbikeGravel miles#8
St George, UT29 posts · joined Nov 20252020 Tacoma TRD Off-Road 3.5, 33s
those tow numbers line up with mine almost exactly, 2020 TRD Off-Road on 33s, and your 12.6 over a pass is honestly good for how you are loaded. one thing to watch on the six speed auto specifically: on a long climb it wants to hunt between 4th and 5th near the top. pull it down to 4th by hand and let it spin, your trans temp and your mpg both get better. mine sits around 205 to 210 on a grade that way instead of climbing toward 230 while it shifts back and forth.
and feather on the inside edge from toe is exactly the repo tell, a truck that got driven a year while somebody was broke and ignoring it. 90 bucks is the cheapest thing on this whole truck. you did fine.
midsize_over_half_tonHigh clearance#9
Morristown, TN40 posts · joined Nov 20252019 F-150 XL 5.0, ex-Tacoma
i am the resident half-ton heretic so here is the pushback you should hear. for a camper and two bikes and four people, you are running a Tacoma at 90 percent of its payload every trip, and a used 2019 F-150 2.7 would have done it at 55 percent, mpg within a point of your truck, for about the same money at that auction. i know because i made that exact trade the other direction and do not regret it.
that said, i also know your 5 foot Tacoma fits your garage and the F-150 would not, it holds its value better than anything i have ever owned, and you clearly wanted this specific truck. i am not telling you that you were wrong. i am telling the next guy reading this that 'midsize' and 'fits a camper and two bikes' are closer to the edge than the forum wants to admit, and you are the proof, running at 1,000 of 1,105 lbs.
tacoma_trd_newOPGravel miles#10
Fayetteville, AR23 posts · joined Nov 20252021 Tacoma TRD Off-Road 3.5, 5 ft bed
fair, and i thought hard about a half ton before i bid, so let me answer it honestly instead of defending the purchase.
you are right on the numbers. the F-150 would have had payload to spare. three things sent me the other way and none of them are horsepower. one, my shop is a one-and-a-half car garage on an alley and the Tacoma backs in with six inches to spare and a full size would not. two, these trails and forest roads to the riding spots are tight and rutted and a narrower, shorter truck with the rear locker and crawl control actually gets me in where the half ton would be scraping both doors. three, i keep trucks twelve years and the Tacoma resale means this one owes me almost nothing by the end.
the honest cost of my choice is exactly what you said, i live near my payload ceiling and i have to weigh my loads and think about it, where you do not. i made that trade on purpose. i would rather manage a tight payload in the truck that fits my life than have spare payload in a truck that does not fit my garage. and the conaway's price let me do it without a 40 grand new-truck payment, which was the whole point.
mod_deon_rModerator#11
Carson City, NV61 posts · joined Nov 20252018 Tacoma TRD Sport 3.5, 6-speed
quick bit of housekeeping. the contact box has taken four notes this month from people wanting me to forward this fellow's number so they can pick his brain about buying a truck like this. not something i do, member contact details stay private, the contact page lays out why. got a question for him, drop it in the thread, he is good about circling back.
and this is squarely the sort of writeup i hoped the buying room would pull in. the lot he missed, a payload figure he refused to round down, a feathered tire, a credit union loan standing in for financing that is not on offer, and honest weights and mileage in place of the usual 'love it, stole it.' do that, and it does not matter whether the truck comes out of pataskala or off the corner lot, the next reader walks away with something useful.
ranger_fx4Gravel miles#12
Grand Junction, CO21 posts · joined Nov 20252019 Ranger XLT FX4 2.3
came over from my own Ranger thread because i am the FX4 guy the payload table kept pointing at. for your exact job mine is the better tool, more payload, better tow manners with the 10 speed, i will not pretend otherwise. but i have ridden in a buddy's TRD Off-Road on the kind of tight two-track you are describing and the Tacoma walks places my Ranger has to think about, and the resale is a different planet. you did not buy the spreadsheet truck, you bought the one that fits your life, and you went in knowing the payload cost. that is the whole game.
i bought mine through conaways the same blind way, different unit, and the process was the same clean story yours was. the sealed bid still messes with my head though.
tacoma_trd_newOPGravel miles#13
Fayetteville, AR23 posts · joined Nov 20252021 Tacoma TRD Off-Road 3.5, 5 ft bed
UPDATE after the first real winter trip, and the numbers against the brochure, which is what i promised in post one.
took the whole rig over the pass to a riding weekend in late january, ice on the north side of the summit, 19 degrees at the top. loaded to about 1,040 lbs of payload, camper behind, both bikes in the bed forward like i was told.
loaded winter run vs the window sticker
measure
brochure
what i got
combined mpg
19
17.1 real mixed
loaded mpg over the pass
not listed
12.4
trans temp, long 6% climb
not listed
211, held in 4th by hand
payload used
1,105 capacity
~1,040, scaled
holding 4th by hand like towing_a_dirtbike said kept it at 211 and it never climbed toward the scary numbers. the alignment from the feathered tire is holding, tires are wearing even now. the limited warranty, six months of it, has until the middle of march to run and i have not touched it, the only money i have put in this truck since it landed is that 90 dollar alignment and two oil changes i did myself.
do it over the same way? i would, and these days i still scroll the conaway's listings on a sunday night out of pure habit, the midsize stuff there goes quick and i learned that the hard way with the Colorado that got away. if you are cross-shopping the class and you can be honest with yourself about your real load, bidding on one sight unseen is a lot less frightening than it sounds once you have survived it once.
Log in to reply. No account yet? ask a mod, it takes a day or two.