Idaho Falls, ID35 posts · joined Nov 20252021 Ranger XLT 2.3, 4x4
2021 Ranger XLT 2.3 EcoBoost 4x4, 10 speed, stock 265/65R17, 33k miles. the window sticker said 20 city and 24 highway and i will admit i bought partly on that number. two years in, my lifetime hand-calc, pump and odometer and a calculator, not the dash, is 19.4. empty at 70 with no wind i can hold 23. the second i hook up the 1,700 lb popup i am at 14 and a half and watching the gauge.
so i want a real table from real trucks. not EPA, not the number your dash flashes at you, which on mine reads about 1.5 high every single time. post your year, engine, tire size and your hand-calculated average, and say whether that is a commuter life or a towing life. the EPA test figures are at fueleconomy.gov if you want to see how far your truck runs from the sticker. i will start it off with mine above.
frontier_pro4xGravel miles#2
Enid, OK26 posts · joined Nov 20252022 Frontier Pro-4X 3.8
2022 Pro-4X, 3.8 V6, 9 speed, stock 265/70R17. here is the part nobody warns you about on the new Frontier. that 310 horse V6 is thirsty. mine hand-calcs 17.8 lifetime and that is mostly flat Oklahoma highway at 70. around town in january with the remote start burning fuel in the driveway it drops into the 15s. i pull a 3,000 lb utility trailer twice a month and that drags it to 14.
the kicker is the old 4.0 five speed Frontiers got about the same mileage with fifty fewer horsepower, so at least this time we got the power for the gas.
colorado_zr2_ownerBackroad regular#3
Durango, CO38 posts · joined Nov 20252020 Colorado ZR2 3.6, 285/75R17
altitude guy, so my numbers are not your numbers and that matters more than people think. 2020 ZR2, 3.6 V6, 8 speed, on 285/70R17 which is a hair under a 33. the bigger tire knocked my speedo off about 6 percent and my mpg off a point and a half before i recalibrated, and folks forget that when they brag about their figures. corrected hand-calc is 16.1 mixed, and up here mixed means a 7,000 foot pass on the way to anything. on a flat run down to Albuquerque i have touched 19.
the 2.8 diesel Colorado owners are all sitting at 25 and grinning and i have learned not to look at them.
midsize_over_half_tonHigh clearance#4
Morristown, TN40 posts · joined Nov 20252019 F-150 XL 5.0, ex-Tacoma
i am going to be the heretic. i had a 2018 Tacoma 3.5 six speed auto and it got 18 and change no matter how i drove it. then i moved to a 2019 F-150 2.7 EcoBoost, which every forum told me would drink more because it is a bigger truck. it gets 19 on the highway and 21 if i keep my foot out of it. the half ton with the little turbo six beat my midsize on fuel.
the only places the Tacoma won were cheaper tires and resale that held like a brick. the 'midsize means good mpg' thing is a story people repeat. pull the two window stickers up on that EPA page and the gap is almost nothing.
real_world_mpgOPBackroad regular#5
Idaho Falls, ID35 posts · joined Nov 20252021 Ranger XLT 2.3, 4x4
pulling it together so somebody searching this in a year gets a straight answer.
Ranger 2.3, me: 19.4 mixed, 23 empty on the highway, 14.5 towing the popup
Frontier 3.8: 17.8 flat highway, low teens towing
Colorado ZR2 3.6 on near-33s: 16.1 in the mountains, 19 flat
Tacoma 3.5 auto: about 18, all day, every day
F-150 2.7 posted for spite: 19 to 21
the pattern i see is that every V6 midsize lives between 17 and 19 and the only real mpg win in the class is the diesel Colorado or Canyon, or driving a four cylinder gently. and every one of us said the dash reads high. hand-calc or it did not happen.
bed_length_debateHigh clearance#6
Chico, CA44 posts · joined Nov 20252017 Tacoma SR5 V6, 6 ft bed
late but one thing that moves mpg more than which engine you picked. a bed rack or a roof rack with a tent on it. i bolted a cheap aluminum bed rack to my Tacoma, changed nothing else, and lost 2 mpg at 70, from 18 to 16, just from the air hitting it on the interstate. pulled the crossbars for the winter and got it straight back.
so before anybody blames the engine, if you are running a rack, a rooftop tent or even a tall whip antenna, that is your missing mileage sitting up there catching wind.
Log in to reply. No account yet? ask a mod, it takes a day or two.